banner

The Era of the Free: A New Model

 

 

Khulud Sahhari

Lecturer at Imam Abdulrahman Bin Faisal University

Welcome to the Era of the Free: A New Model

 

 

The Evolution of Free: An Introduction

20th century free

Free is such a powerful word. It has the uncanny ability to elicit strong responses. To the consumer, “free” is instinctively met with excitement. After all, who wouldn’t want to get a product or a service without paying for it? But the same consumer also asks, “What is the catch?” Experience tells us that most of the time, free is not really free. As Anderson (2010) explained, “Free is a marketing tool where companies give away one thing to create demand for another” (p. 17).  Although marketers have used such a technique since the 18th century, the commercial use of “free” was amplified in the 20th century. Mobile networks have introduced the idea of “free phones” for a year-long commitment to their plan. Consumer brands lure us to buy their products (even if it is not within our budget) under the guise of  a “buy one get one free promo.” Amazon gets us to fill our shopping carts through “free shipping” once we reach a certain amount. In all of these examples mentioned, the concept of “free” is a smokescreen, designed to make us believe that we are getting additional value when, in reality, these “free” items or services have already been tucked into the cost that we paid for. That is why we have become weary of free; we have come to equate it with gimmicks.  There is no such thing as truly free. Or is there?

21st century free

According to Anderson (2010), “free” came from the Latin words, liber (which means freedom) and gratis (which means with thanks). Free, as it was intended, meant “to give freely.” But it seems that, in the face of trade, free has no place in modern economics. This is most evident in the collapse of the Soviet Union. As the communist ideology fell, capitalism rose. That being said, there are still manifestations of free ingrained in the fabrics of society. As Anderson (2010) pointed out, there is the concept of progressive taxation that provides free benefits to those who can’t afford them. There is also the idea of charity in which individuals and organizations give to those in need without any expectation of anything in return. But those examples are confined within the sociopolitical sphere. Free, in its true essence, seems to be ironically absent in the “Free Market.” Then, the 21st century came along.

“The most disruptive way to enter a market is to vaporize the economics of existing business models” (Anderson, 2010, p. 35). And what better way to disrupt the market than make your offer free – no hidden cost, no gimmick, no commitment. Trends have shown that free significantly increases participation, develops brand affinity and creates demand. Anderson (2010) illustrated this point through the Microsoft case study. For the longest time, the company has attempted to fight the piracy of its software in China. After much effort, they realized that piracy will never stop. Moreover, company executives had the insight that there is an opportunity in piracy. Free use equals free exposure. People who can’t afford the paid version (yet), use the pirated version. When they see the value of the product, there is a high probability that they will be paying customers later on. True enough, Microsoft remains to be the market leader in China. Taking it to a level further, Microsoft has released a free version of their products that people can access. Should they want to upgrade to a professional version, they are free to do so. Free in the 21st century does not mean loss. On the contrary, free seems to be the way to a new profit model.

But it is more complicated than we think. This essay will explain how this new concept has come about and how businesses, as well as consumers, are navigating the free economy. Moreover, this paper will also uncover the intangible cost of the free to individuals and society at large. Finally, the writer will connect how the free model affects libraries.

The Road to the Free Economy

The Digital Age

Before writing Free: The Future of Radical Price, Anderson wrote The Long Tail. This book focuses on how the Internet has shattered the economic and cultural beliefs about “hits.” According to Anderson (2008), markets thrived on the idea of best sellers and blockbusters.  He went on to explain how traditional economics were centralized on limited choices. Based on what was offered, consumers gravitated toward what they consider to be the “best.”  Of course, “best” was measured based on what their friends said, what the media showcased, and what businesses advertised. It has become a cycle through which consumers pushed the next best thing, and the markets pushed back with more of the said product or service. This approach created a purchase bubble that highlighted the few and ignored the rest.  The Internet turned this model upside down, offering seemingly unlimited choices and making them accessible for free or almost free. As a result,“ the markets have fragmented into millions of niches” (Anderson, 2008, p. 53). True enough, now, consumers can live stream songs and build their own playlists. People can download audiobooks and e-books to their heart’s content. The digital age has even circumvented large communication network companies by offering different services of interacting with people. There is now Facebook Messenger and Viber, both free of charge. At this point, it is worthy to note that the Web is unique in that it can offer a plethora of things because of two critical elements. First, the cost of production has become so low thanks to the improvement in technology (i.e. faster bandwidth, larger storage and more sophisticated information processing). Second, the Internet has moved away from the material to the ideal. No longer constrained by physical barriers (except for a few optic fiber connection), ideas can flow freely from one part of the world to another.

Not only did the Internet introduce free in its present form, but it has also introduced different versions of free. There is Google, which offers more than 90% of its products and services at zero cost. Then, there is the open-source aspect where programmers and developers make their work available to the public. Finally, there is the Free and Paid model (“Freemium”). This is the essence of the free alongside the premium. For example, if you only need the basic features, you can always access Microsoft online. However, should the time come that you and your needs require more advanced features, you can opt to pay for upgrade. In the same manner, you can build your own program based on the code instruction in open source forum, or you can pay so that someone will do it for you. “The Free plus Paid approach can span the full psychology of consumerism” (Anderson, 2010, p. 52).

The Internet also has blurred the line between content consumers and producers, creating a new breed of online users: the prosumers. Gerhardt (2014) defined prosumers as “the eager adopters of the web who create content as much as they consume them” (p. 3). The prosumers are the bloggers, the active members of different social media platforms and forumers who exchange information, advice, as well as stories. Instead of passively accepting information, prosumers are empowered to pick and choose the content they will pay attention to and the content they will share to their network. One sure way of engaging prosumers is through Free offerings.

Duplicating the Free Economy Offline

While the digital space is at the forefront of the free economy, it is not confined to the Internet. Different companies across different industries have adapted to the new model. This is most apparent in the publishing world. Now, you can see free newspapers and magazines. At this point, one can’t help but wonder, “how do free newspapers create profit?”

Along with the development of a new model comes the rise of new currency: information. As Robertson (2009) pointed out, more and more companies are learning to sell information in the form of buyers’ insights (demographics and psychographics) that advertisers are more than willing to pay for. Going back to the publishing example, publications have learned that one marketing advantage of free is that it allows you to reach more people that you would not have reached otherwise. And the more people you connect with, the more information you can gather. The more data you have, the better your bargaining chip to advertisers.

Google: The Flagbearer of the Free

Free is now the name of the game. And arguably, there is no better player in the free landscape than Google. No other company has grown so much in a short span of time – all while giving away stuff. With a net worth of $20 billion, how does Google make it work?

In the Google framework, free is not optional; it is the default. Indeed, most of Google’s products and services are free – Gmail, Google Docs and YouTube. In his book, Bradley (2015) dissected how Google made an empire by handing things out for free. First, there is innovation. Google has a knack for creating offerings that people actually need and want. This guarantees that consumers will use Google products and services. Second, Google has built a reliable knowledge base designed to help people with their problems. When people have questions, the first thing that they do is search for answers on Google. Because both are free in nature, the Google ecosystem is able to reach the global market and be part of consumers’ daily lives. And herein lies the gold mine. Google collects every question, every keyword and every search, and then organizes them into databases. These pieces of information translate to valuable data advertisers need to target the right consumers, produces the right content and shows them at the right time. “89% of Google’s revenue comes from its advertising arms: ad words, and ad sense” (Bradley, 2015, p. 5). Bradley (2015) further explained that Google was able to monetize information by creating a system by which companies compete to be shown first when a particular keyword comes up. And because Google has a plethora of marketing insights about its users, it is able to match the ads most relevant to potential consumers, making it a win-win situation for everyone.

But what makes Google immensely successful is its basic principle of providing users with helpful content free of charge. One such example is Google Scholar. Using the  Internet portal, Google Scholar is a new way of researching academic literature. Compared to a bibliographical databases, Google Scholar finds documents based on keywords and terms. Just like the Google methodology, Google Scholar ranks literature based on the most popular, which in the academic setting is the most cited (De Graff, De Graff, & Romesburg, 2013). True enough, its accessibility 24/7 and its large scope make the service attractive to students and researchers.

Without a doubt, Google has spearheaded the free economy as we know it. Not only did the company show a free model works, but it also has largely profited from it. As a matter of fact, Google remains unmatched in the free space so much so that Bradley (2015) referred to the tech giant’s dominance as Google-opoly.  According to Anderson (2010), “While everyone can use the Free business model, only the number one company can get really rich with it” (p. 100). By being the first to recognize the revenue potential of the free, Google has secured its place in this new world.

The Cost of the Free Economy

“Money may not be involved, but that does not make it free” (Herrera-Gonzales, 2008, par. 5).  Hence, we go back to the question, “how free is free?” While the free economy has provided service with no charge, it is not devoid of consequences. One such consequence can be observed in the field of education. Because technology (or a large chunk of it) is free, students have greatly depended on it to the point that it is now seen as a shortcut to learning. As Cookson (2009) explained, “Many believe that we can Google, blog, Skype and tweet our way to enlightenment” (p. 9).  Many research studies have shown that the path to knowledge begins with data collection, moving on to data organization and finally application in real-life. However, with the influx of information, most students stop at data collection. Moreover, many individuals drown from too much material that discerning between what is fact from fiction, and what is useful from nonsense, becomes doubly challenging. Many end up accepting every bit of data as gospel truth. Hence, the sarcasm that “If it’s on the net; it must be true.” As a result, there is as much misinformation as much as there is information.

Another cost of the free model is the conflict with intellectual property rights, causing what Lichtman (2011) referred to as the “gridlock economy.”  Case in point: Google Books. Google uses a proprietary software that scans books then uploads it online for search purposes. However, Google Books does not ask permission from the authors and the publishers, leading to a collective lawsuit against the company. To Google’s defense, CEO Eric Schmidt released a statement: “The book search project would be an enormous boon to society, increasing the visibility and accessibility that the need for permission is not necessary” (Lichtman, 2011, p 135). Moreover, Google assured publishers and authors that they will not publish the whole book and that users cannot view the excerpts of the book too many times. The Google Books example illustrates how the Free Economy erodes current policies, regulations and institutions.

The Impact of the Free on Libraries

So what does the library have to do with the free? This new economic landscape presents an opportunity and a challenge. To this point, it is important to understand the realities of libraries. First, there is a close relationship between libraries and publishers.  Libraries put a lot of money in purchasing journals for their users.  “These purchases are expensive, annual price increase, and lock-in agreements” (Wilson, 2012, p. 260). In contrast, open access journals allow libraries and users to gain access to content for free. Moreover, these journals are available online, making them  accessible 24/7. However, many libraries still opt to partner with big publishers because of the second reality: Libraries’ success are largely dependent on reputation. This reputation is tied to the content and quality of resources. Big publishers are credible because of years of experience. As such, established and aspiring authors want to post their works with these publishers. In the same manner, users prioritize these publishers based on their positive reputation, creating a profitable cycle. What libraries can do is work closely with open access journals to build their credibility and reputation. They can be involved in the process as well as content that most users want and need.

Another opportunity for libraries is to expand their services. One consequence of free is that people have come to expect it all the time. Free is equated with accessibility (Kennwell, 2005). In the past, libraries have been the pillar of knowledge and information. Now, computers and online technologies are slowly taking the library’s place. Chan (2006) reported that an average of 2 million e-books are downloaded every month. An average of 200,000 education sites are also visited monthly. The reason for this shift is that these resources are available all the time, so as long as there is Internet. To keep up, libraries have begun creating online portals (with search capabilities) and digitizing books.  School libraries are also working to strengthen Internet bandwidth for a better infrastructure support.

What libraries should address next is how they can offer non-print resources that users can access (i.e.,.e videos). This is in line with the rise of online educational videos through Hulu and Netflix. Most of these videos are also free of charge.

Finally, the libraries have the potential to capitalize on the freemium model for supplementary income. This new revenue source can help augment libraries’ tightening budget. The important thing is libraries should apply the freemium model right. Klapperstuck (2009) discussed the right and wrong approach when it comes to the freemium model in the context of libraries. Following the law of supply and demand, the Dallas Public Library charges for bestsellers but keeps other sources free. Their reason is to make the library experience more efficient by limiting wait times and holds for an item. Those willing to pay will pay for a high demand item. On the other hand, the East Brunswick Public Library charges for every reservations. As a result, users moved to another library because they feel the charge is unfair. According to Kapperstuck (2009), “The important lesson to remember here is that if you must charge, find a way to add value. Simply charging something, especially services that used to be free could ruin a library’s goodwill” (par. 7).

The Future of the Library in the Free Economy

Trends show that free is the new phase of today’s economy. But its impacts go beyond the demonetization of products and services. A free model will affect every sector of society, especially information and knowledge. Libraries have always been a learning hub. To be able to fulfill its mission, libraries must be fluid and flexible to adapt to this ever-changing world. But given that libraries have stood empires, wars and the test of time, I am confident it will be able to keep up with this new economic landscape.

References

Anderson, C. (2008). The long tail: Why the future of business is selling less of more. New York: Hachette Books.

Anderson, C. (2010). Free: The future of a radical price. New York: Hachette Books.

Bradley, S. (2015). Win the game of Googleopoly: Unlocking the secret strategy of search engines. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley and Sons Inc.

Chan, E. (2006). E-book technology and its impact on libraries. 9th Collaborative Electronic Commerce Technology & Research Conference. Brisbane, AU: Swinburne University of Technology.

Cookson Jr., P.W. (2009). What Would Socrates Say? Educational Leadership, 57(1) 8-14.

De Graff, J.V., De Graff, N., and Romesburg, H. (2013). Literature searches with Google Scholar: Knowing what you are and are not getting. GSA Today, 23(10), 44-45.

Gerhardt, W. (2014). Prosumers: A new growth opportunity. San Jose: Cisco Publishing.

Herrera-Gonzales, F. (2008). Is our future really $0? MISES Institute.

Retrieved from https://mises.org/library/our-future-really-0

Kennwell, S. (2005). Fewer dollars, fewer books, but many more words: The state of campus libraries. New York: Bookseller and Publisher.

Lichtman, D. (2011). Google Book Search in the gridlock economy. Arizona Law Review, 53(1), 131-143.

Robertson, V. (2011). Information currency: The new green. New York: New York University Press.

Wilson, K. (2012). What librarians can learn from cable television: Thoughts on transformative business models and their impact on the business of libraries. Serials Review, 38(4), 258-261.

https://powderencouraged.com/zht6b3bs66?key=8523542c4aaf6f083ce56f74bd271319
https://powderencouraged.com/w3m6c9b5?key=af8b4909c0965493e9682d74bb50a646
https://powderencouraged.com/ksq5rgwdmh?key=b5b47a0d83f8742dcf71d4de8ef00494
https://powderencouraged.com/bkcduddx?key=0252cc21d0f4e0ae5f53245940611301
×
error: Content is protected !!