The Provisions of the Financial Leasing Contract according to Islamic and Kuwaiti Legislations
Dr. Mohammad Salem Alhihi ?
الدكتور محمد سالم الهيهي
Assistant Professor of Commercial Law, Kuwait International Law School
أستاذ القانون التجاري المساعد ، كلية القانون الكويتية العالمية
Dr. Mahmoud Saleem Alshwaiyat ?
الدكتور محمد سالم الشويات
associate Professor of Islamic Economics, Kuwait International Law School
أستاذ مشارك في الاقتصاد الإسلامي ، كلية القانون الكويتية العالمية
الملخص:
هذه الورقة تهدف لمناقشة موضوعيين رئيسيين وهما الأحكام الشرعية المنظمة لعقد التأجير التمويلي، ثم بيان القواعد القانونية التي تنظم هذا العقد في دولة الكويت. حيث ان عقد التأجير التمويلي هو نشاطا تمويليا للمشاريع الاقتصادية بما تحتاجه إليه من أصول رأسمالية سواء كانت منقولات أو عقارات، حيث يتم التمويل من خلال عقد حديث نسبياً ذو خصائص خاصة تجمع بين الإيجار والبيع في نفس الوقت. عندما يتم تمويل المشاريع من خلال عقد التأجير التمويلي لا تحتاج الشركات طالبة التمويل اللجوء الى عقد القرض النقدي البسيط، ولا الى استئجار الأصول من خلال عقد الإيجار العادي المعروف في القانون المدني. من الناحية الشرعية فلا يوجد ما يمنع من استحداث عقود جديدة تقتضيها متطلبات العصر من اجل تحقق المصالح المشروعة إذا توافر فيها الأركان والخصائص التي لا يخالف أحكام الشرع الحنيف. كذلك يعتبر عقد التأجير التمويلي كوسيلة جيدة لاستثمار الأموال الفائضة لدى المؤسسات المالية بضمان بقاء ملكية العين المؤجرة لصالح المؤسسة المالية لحين سداد كامل الاقساط من قبل المستأجر. بالنتيجة من خلال هذا العقد تضمن المشاريع الاقتصادية حصولها على ما تحتاج الية من أصول رأسمالية إذا لم يكون لديها القدرة على شرائها، أو لتفادي استخدام كامل رأس مالها النقدي في شراء الأصول الرسمالية، مع إمكانية تملك الأصول في نهاية المدة الإيجارية.
وعقد التأجير التمويلي مطبق من قبل المؤسسات المالية في الكويت وخصوصا الإسلامية منها، الا أنه لا يوجد قانون مستقل ينظم هذا العقد رغم وجود تشريع يجيز تأسيس شركات الإجارة ولكنه لم يتضمن أي أحكام تنظم عملية التأجير التمويلي، سوف يتم تناول الموضع من خلال ثلاث مباحث رئيسية وهي المبحث الاول حول المفهوم العام للتأجير التمويلي نشأته وأهميته، والمبحث الثاني يبحث في أطراف عقد التأجير التمويلي وخصائصه وصوره العملية، أما المبحث الثالث فيتناول البنية التشريعية والقانونية لعقد التأجير التمويلي والواقع التطبيقي له في الكويت وأثر جائحة كورونا على التزامات أطراف علاقته العقدية.
الكلمات المفتاحية: عقد التأجير التمويلي، الإجارة المنتهية بالتمليك، البيع الإيجاري، الإيجار بشرط البيع.
Abstract
This research aims to discuss two main topics, which are the legal provisions regulating the financial leasing contract and clarifying the legal rules regulating this contract in the State of Kuwait. The financial leasing contract is a financing activity for economic projects that provides them with what they need in the form of capital assets, whether movables or real estate, without resorting to the simple cash loan contract, nor the lease of assets in the ordinary lease contract known in civil law, through a relatively recent contract that combines rent and sale at the same time. From the Islamic point of view, leasing contract can be conducted in a form that does not contradict Islamic finance rules. From an investment point of view, the financial leasing is a good way to invest the surplus funds of financial institutions by ensuring that the ownership of the leased property remains in their hands until the full payment is made by the lessee. The financial leasing contract has several advantages. It ensures that economic projects obtain what they need from capital assets in the event they are unable to purchase them and help them to avoid using their entire cash capital in the purchase of machinery and real estate, as well as enable them to escape borrowing. On top of that, it gives the lessee the opportunity to own the asset at the end of the contract. In Kuwait, the financial leasing contract is applied by financial institutions, especially Islamic ones, but there is no independent law regulating this contract. Despite the existence of legislation that permits the establishment of leasing companies, it does not include any provisions regulating the process of financial leasing.
Keywords: leasing contract, Ijarah ends with ownership, rental sale, rent with right to own.
Importance and Inspiration of this Research
The importance of the research lies in clarifying the legal provisions of the financial leasing contract, as it is one of the contracts that are utilized by Islamic financial institutions in Kuwait due to its ability to achieve profit and guarantee rights. It is not considered a usurious transaction since it is authorized through the application of special legal controls set by financial and legal scholars. The importance of this research is apparent in relation to the legal aspect of the contract, despite the importance of using it as a means to finance various businesses. There is a law in Kuwait that permits the incorporation of leasing companies without including special provisions for the financial lease contract. Additionally, there are some provisions in some laws in Kuwait that may be useful in finding a legislative basis for regulating this contract.
Research problem
The research problem is represented in the absence of a special legislation that includes the legal provisions governing and regulating this contract in Kuwait. There is no legislation specialized in regulating the financial leasing contract, despite the existence of legislation permitting the incorporation of leasing companies, even though the latter does not include any provisions regulating the process of financial leasing. The study reflects the researchers’ endeavor to bring the attention of the Kuwaiti legislator to the necessity of creating such legislation; which will have a significant impact on moving the wheel of development in various economic sectors in general and in the real estate and construction sector in particular.
Research objective
This research aims to discuss two main topics, which are the legal provisions regulating the financial leasing contract, and clarifying the legal rules regulating this contract in the State of Kuwait. This is applied from a practical point of view by financial institutions without a special law regulating the rights and obligations of the parties to the lease contract financing, which leads to many legal disputes. Such disputes are resolved through resorting to general legal rules and their procedures which are not encompassed by the financial and business sector. Regardless, this sector is in dire need of special laws of a relatively urgent nature.
Research Methodology
The main themes in this research will be discussed using the descriptive and analytical approaches, by describing the research problem with all its effects on ground to determine its most important causes. Then, the research will take an in-depth analytical look at all of the above to come up with possible solutions by drafting them in results and recommendations to direct them to the concerned and competent authorities related to this contract and all its requirements.
Search Plan
The topic will be dealt with through three main sections. The first section will discuss the general concept of financial leasing, its origin and importance. The second section will look at the parties to the financial leasing contract, its characteristics and practical images. The third section will deal with the legislative and legal structure of the financial leasing contract and its applied reality in Kuwait and the impact of the Corona virus pandemic on the obligations of the parties to its contractual relationship.
Chapter 1: The Emergence of Financial Leasing, its Concept and its Importance
Preamble
The financial lease contract represents a financing activity for economic projects; including its capital assets, whether movables or real estate, through a relatively recent contract – innominate contracts – that has its own characteristics and combines lease and sale at the same time without resorting to a simple cash loan contract, or leasing assets through the ordinary lease contract known in the Civil Law. According to laws that took the lead in developing the idea of a financial leasing contract; such as US Commercial Law and the UNIDROIT Convention on International Financial Leasing of 1998; the capital assets subject to the financial lease contract should not be in the possession of the lessor. These assets must be owned or prepared according to the lessee’s request by a third party (the supplier). The lessee needs the assets in order to use them in his/her business, but he/she does not have the financial ability to purchase them. Hence, the lessor buys them from the supplier and then leases them to the lessee under a long-term contract, with the possibility of a condition that enables the lessee to own the assets at the end of the contract period. This depends on the terms of the contract and the value of the rental installment. The installments that the lessee is obligated to pay are usually higher than the normal rent premium; because the premium here includes a part of the original price that was paid to the supplier in addition to a reasonable profit margin for the lessor. Recently, the financial lease contract has evolved in several forms, which may differ from one country to another as a result of the development that took place on this contract. The right to own assets by the lessee is not a condition for implementing provisions of the financial lease contract; as is the case in the Jordanian law . Unlike the Jordanian Law, the Egyptian law requires the availability of the purchase option for the lessee for the validity of the financial lease contract .
Likewise, from the Sharia point of view, nothing prevents the creation of a new contract if its components and characteristics are present in a way that does not contradict the provisions of Sharia, and the requirements of the times and the need of people, provided that it does not contradict the Quran or Sunnah of the Prophet . Some believe, after an extensive study of more than one contractual theory, that it is a special, self-contained contract distinguished by its components and conditions . This contract was called in Islamic jurisprudence as the rent-to-own contract .
1.The Development of the Financial Leasing Contract
The idea of financial leasing is based on providing financing from one party to another with capital assets without the use of traditional contracts such as the cash loan or the usual rental of items through the lease contract. It shall be done through the financer or the lessor renting or buying properties and real estate in order to rent them, according to the needs of the other party (the financier or the lessee). At the end of the lease term, the lessee has the right to own what has been leased if he/she fulfills the conditions of this contract agreed upon or specified by the legislator. Therefore, the finance lease contract has been defined as a financial transaction intended to enable the lessee to benefit from the property during the lease period and grant him/her the right to own the property at the end of the term if he/she fulfills his/her obligations during the lease term .
The most important obligations of the parties to this contract are that the lessor is obligated to deliver the leased property and enable the lessee to benefit from it. At the same time, the lessee is obligated to maintain and pay the agreed rent while bearing the consequences of the loss of the leased property and any other taxes, maintenance and insurance costs . The initial applications of this system were limited to the movables subject to the contract. As for real estate, its use was delayed due to the difficulties, legal obstacles and procedures required by the nature of contracts received on real estate, but after the issuance of legal legislation regulating these outstanding issues, real estate entered the subject of the contract, just like movables .
The origin of the establishment of financial leasing contracts dates back to the United States of America in 1952. The reason behind this idea was the need for money to purchase capital assets such as machines for a business, but the owner of that business was unable to provide guarantees that would enable him/her to borrow and was unable to obtain the required assets. As a result, the idea of buying the capital assets (i.e. machines) and renting them back while giving the lessee the right to own the leased assets has emerged . The American market has started to expand the application of this contract internally, due to the profits and returns that have been achieved through it. The application of the financial leasing contract moved to European countries because of its benefits. Among the first European countries to implement this system was England through the opening of branches for American financial leasing companies in the early sixties. This system then appeared in France in 1962, followed by the Netherlands, Germany, Italy and Spain and other European countries . The application of the financial leasing contract also extended to developing countries in Latin America, Africa and Asia, and this includes the Islamic world in general and the Arab world in particular. Therefore, conferences were held to discuss the possibility of accepting or rejecting this system, and during that time many companies rushed to implement this contract due to the guaranteed commercial benefit and the lack of risks. For example, in Kuwait, Law No. 12 of 1998 was enacted for the purpose of licensing the establishment of leasing and investment companies. This is in addition to the Financial Leasing Law No. 45 of 2008 in Jordan, Federal Law No. 8 of 2018 in the UAE regarding financial leasing. Other countries have also followed suit.
2.The Importance of Financial Leasing
The importance of the financial leasing contract is that it is the best means that enables businesses to quickly and sustainably obtain capital assets when needed, with the possibility of owning assets after a period of time. The financial lease contract is resorted to due to the difficulty of providing sufficient guarantees by the applicant for the purchase of capital assets such as machines or real estate, or because of the unwillingness of businesses to take loans and bear the benefits and risks in the event of direct purchase of assets. Through the financial leasing contract, the solution was to guarantee the rights of all parties without the need for personal or material guarantees from the financier or the applicant for financing. As for the financer, there is a real guarantee by retaining the ownership of the asset (the subject of the contract), which enables the financer to recover his/her money if the other party breaches their obligations. The importance of the financial leasing contract is that it is a binding legal means that preserves the rights of all parties in the financing process in terms of ensuring the proper implementation of financing operations while ensuring the right of the financer . According to the description and provisions of the financial leasing that come into force, the benefits and importance of it can be summarized as follows:
First: Financial leasing achieves great interests for all parties to the contractual relationship, as it guarantees the financer his/her rights from falling into the trap of the financier’s procrastination or non-fulfillment of his/her contractual obligations. This in addition to ensuring cash flows over the duration of the contract, considering its relative length, through payments made by the financier successively. It also ensures that creditors will not be compete with him/her over this asset in the event of the bankruptcy of the financier, since this asset shall not be part of the fulfillment of debts. As for the lessee, this is considered a suitable alternative to obtain capital assets during the expansion and renewal of capital assets. It also constitutes a legitimate alternative to the method of forbidden usurious lending.
Second: Financial leasing advances sustainable development by providing sufficient sources of capital and without cumbersome guarantees to enable owners of small and medium enterprises to implement their ideas and visions to achieve their investment dreams. This was almost impossible due to the lack of guarantees required through other investment methods. It is expected that this contract will have a significant impact on economic life in general, if it is activated. Additionally, it is true that it will not solve all the intractable problems and issues such as poverty, unemployment and others, but it will contribute to providing a reasonable percentage of positivity in resolving these issues.
Third: This contract constitutes a golden opportunity for both the financial and banking financial institutions of an Islamic nature on the one hand, and the public on the other hand. This is in regards to getting rid of the scourge of usury with the presence of this effective alternative if it is applied according to Islamic principles and in a manner that suits Islamic financial institutions and their work system. However, there are some obstacles which led to failure in activating this method. By extrapolating the reality of the situation in Islamic financial institutions in general, we find that they focus their investments on the Murabaha method for the purchase orderer, despite the suspicions and criticism leveled against this method. Other methods such as speculation (Mudarabah), advance payment and financial leasing have not been activated on a larger scale.
3.The Concept and Definition of a Financial Leasing Contract
This innovative contract aims to regulate the tripartite relationship between the supplier, the lessor and the lessee. This contract guarantees the rights of all parties before each other and ensures that businesses obtain capital financing with contracts binding on the financer. This contract also creates a legal relationship aimed primarily at financing by enabling the financier to use the capital assets such as movables or real estate that he/she needs and not to finance their purchase . In other words, the financial lease contract is done through special conditions that combine the characteristics of the lease and sales contract at the same time. The lessor has no right to terminate the contract before the expiry of the term on his/her own. The lessee is also granted the right to own the property at the end of the term, or to renew or terminate the contract. This contract is a consensual contract, and one of the contracts of continuous duration in terms of time. It is of a special nature; it is neither a sale nor a lease contract, but rather a mixture of both. The contract was named according to the real intent of it, as many names and terms have been used for the subject of financial leasing, such as: the cover lease for sale, the purchase lease, the rent-to-own lease, the lease purchase, the lease finance … etc . This wide multiplicity of terms is in itself a cause for ambiguity, especially if we attempt to look into these concepts and whether they are unified or synonymous with each other. These terms and concepts reflect various characteristics, which increases the ambiguity of the situation since some are considered synonyms while others are not . Moreover, we do not have an agreement between the theory and the applications regarding the nature of each concept and its characteristics. Thus, readers who are interested in this topic find a great deal of trouble in researching, investigating and clarifying its subject and purpose . For this reason, the legislation differed regarding the adaptation of the financial leasing contract. The different concepts share the aspect of leasing, but they may differ according to the leased objects, their nature, or the nature of the legal relationship that takes place between its parties, or any special conditions added to it. However, what concerns us is to arrive at a definition that deals with these concepts in a conciliatory manner, so that it is general and comprehensive, enabling us to compare it later with its counterpart from an Islamic perspective. Some definitions of financial leasing can be presented, including :
1. Financial leasing contract: “The lease contract through which all the risks and expenses of ownership of the asset are transferred from the lessor to the lessee, whe whether ownership of the asset is transferred in the end or not. ”
2. Financial leasing contract: “It is a lease contract that transfers almost all the risks and benefits of ownership of an asset (the leased property) whether ownership of the asset is transferred in the end or not .”
3. “It is a contract whereby the lessee is able to use and exploit the leased assets he/she needs without the need to purchase or own them during a relatively long period equivalent to the economic life of the assets or their approximation in return for an agreed upon rental value in the financial lease contract. It may also include the option to own the asset at the end of the contract term. This is according to the principle, with the tenant’s commitment to maintenance and insurance during the term of the contract. ”
From a legal point of view, financial leasing has been defined in more than one way before statutory laws, with some discrepancies between them in terms of focus of the definition, for example: The Jordanian legislator defined financial leasing as the activity that the lessor practices by owning the leased from his/her own or borrowed money, and leasing it to a lessee in return for a rent allowance to enable him/her to own, use and benefit from the property in accordance with the provisions of the lease contract. The law has specified that the subject of the contract in this case is all movable or immovable money that can be benefitted from by using it repeatedly while leaving said property in the same condition existing at the time it was delivered to the Lessee. It does not include money, commercial papers or securities .
UAE law defines the relationship that is established through a financial lease contract as the relationship in which the lessor owns the leased property for the purposes of leasing it, and leases it to the lessee for a specified period under an independent contract. The law specified that the subject of the contract is the leased property, which is any movable property or real estate over which usufruct applies by use while leaving said property in the same condition existing at the time it was delivered to the Lessee . The Kuwaiti legislator did not provide any definition of this relationship, and merely stipulated the permissibility of licensing the establishment of Kuwaiti shareholding companies for leasing and investment with Kuwaiti or foreign capital . The Kuwaiti legislator did not regulate this contract, but left it to the rule of the general rules regulating commercial contracts .
Through the previous definitions, we find that financial leasing is based on a basic principle, which is the existence of a rental relationship in principle. However, the difference is that this relationship gives the tenant the right to own the rented assets under certain conditions if he/she wishes to do so after a period of time. This is why we find that (rental sale) (lease associated with the promise of sale) (lease ending with ownership) are synonyms to financial leasing. We note that all of them are within the limits of (sale) and (rent) with some minor differences. As a result, the financial lease contract can be defined as: a contract through which the lessee can benefit from the capital assets (real estate or movables) owned by the lessor in return for a specific rental value paid through installments in a specific period of time approximating the economic life of the use of the leased property. It also means the lessee’s commitment to insurance and necessary maintenance of the assets throughout the period of the contract, given that the lessor is obligated to sell the asset to the lessee during or at the end of the period if the lessee wishes to do so, or to renew the contract if he/she does not want to buy it . Based on the above, financial leasing can be defined from an Islamic perspective as follows: it is a method of Islamic financing whereby the financer (the lessor) owns the benefit of a capital asset (real estate or movable) owned by him/her in return for the lessee’s obligation to pay a specified financial compensation within the limits of the value of the capital asset, and within a specified period of time in a savings account with an Islamic financial institution according to a specific mechanism, provided that the financer is obligated to sell this capital asset or give it to the financier at the end of the specified period based on a prior promise.
Chapter 2: The Parties to the Financial Leasing Contract, its Characteristics and Forms
1.The parties to the financial leasing contract
The financial leasing relationship is based on the idea of a distinct contractual relationship that facilitates financing and at the same time guarantees the rights of all parties and achieves their interests . The financial lease contract achieves the common interests of its parties, namely the lessor and the lessee, and sometimes another party, which is the supplier , if the assets were not already with the lessor. Many modern laws such as the Egyptian or Jordanian law did not require the existence of a supplier to implement the provisions of the financial lease contract.
The lessor is the party who invests his/her money through coordination with the lessee by providing real estate or movables that the latter needs for his/her business. According to the various laws, the lessor must be a financial institution licensed to carry out financing activities, as this was stipulated in the introduction to the laws regulating this contract or through a law relating to financial leasing companies, as is the case in Kuwait .
As for the lessee, it is a party that seeks to obtain financing by obtaining capital assets from real estate or movables that are required for production and through a financial leasing contract. In this contract, the lessee is obligated to make payments during the contract period amounting to the money paid by the lessor, in addition to a profit margin that is close to the so-called full coverage of the value of the assets with the possibility of the lessee owning the money at the end of the contract under certain conditions. Legislations differed in regards the necessity of a condition in favor of the lessee in owning the asset at the end of the period. The Egyptian law does not consider the financial lease contract that does not include the tenant’s right to ownership . The Jordanian law explicitly indicated that it does not require for the validity of the financial lease contract that it guarantees the right to own assets by the lessee , unlike the Egyptian law which requires the existence of a purchase option clause in favor of the lessee for the validity of the financial lease contract . The most important obligations of the lessee are to maintain the rent and insurance, in a manner that is similar to the provisions of the lease contract, because the survival of the asset is the real guarantee of the right of the lessor until the end of the contract.
As for the supplier, as stated in the current US unified commercial legalization, the supplier is a major party to the financial leasing contract. The supplier is the one who has the assets in his/her possession or prepares them according to the tenant’s request, then the lessor is enables to buy them and then re-lease them to the lessee . Through this provision, we note that the US legislator was prevented from choosing, manufacturing or supplying assets outside the financial lease contract that he/she wishes to lease. The financial lease contract, according to the US concept, did not grant the lessee the right at the end of the contract to purchase the equipment subject of the contract. Therefore, the lessee has one of two options only: to extend the financial lease contract, and to return the leased assets to the lessor, who has the right to sell them or lease them back to another person . We also find that the UNIDROIT Convention on International Financial Leasing 1988 stipulated in the second paragraph of Article 1 that: “the financial leasing transaction referred to in the previous paragraph is a transaction which includes the following characteristics :
a. The lessee specifies the equipment and selects the supplier without relying primarily on the skill and judgment of the lessor;
b. The equipment is acquired by the lessor in connection with a leasing agreement which, to the knowledge of the supplier, either has been made or is to be made between the lessor and the lessee; and
c. The rentals payable under the leasing agreement are calculated so as to take into account in particular the amortisation of the whole or a substantial part of the cost of the equipment.
We note, according to what is currently being worked on in comparative laws, and as a result of the innovation in the financial leasing contract, that it has become acceptable to take place between two parties, when the lessor is the owner, or he/she buys the assets and leases them. However, to implement the provisions of the financial lease contract, there must be an option to own the assets by the lessee so that the contract differs from the normal lease contract, or the term of the contract is the life span of the asset, and the rental includes the price of the asset plus a profit margin. On the other hand, if the period is short and the total amount paid by the lessee is not equal to the value of the asset, then the provisions of the ordinary lease contract must be applied, and the provisions of the financial lease contract must be excluded. In this case, the contract is called an operating lease.
The operational lease is a relatively short term contract, as this period does not cover the economic life of the capital asset subject of the contract. In this case, the lessee does not want a long-term commitment, especially if the assets he/she needs, such as machinery and cars are subject to technological development. Here, he/she has an opportunity to update through a short-term contract and order modern products. At the same time, this constitutes an opportunity for the lessor to re-lease the assets and benefit from them for a longer period .
2. The characteristics of the financial lease contract
This contract is a long term contract, which usually approximates the operational life of the capital asset subject of the contract, which gives the financer the opportunity to recover the value of the asset, with a reasonable profit margin through rental payments. Additionally, this contract is characterized by the agreement of its parties that it cannot be canceled before the expiry of its specified period. The consequences of maintenance and insurance often fall on the lessee, while the two parties may agree that the ownership of the asset at the end of the contract term will be transferred to the financier, and by the mechanism that is agreed upon. Therefore, this contract is distinguished from the ordinary lease and from the ordinary sales contract. Hence, it is a novel contract of a special nature, which requires examining its reality and the extent of its legality.
The most important characteristics of financial leasing are as follows:
First: Financial leasing is not a sale contract, although it includes many provisions of the sale contract, especially in its final stages, such as handing over the property subject of the contract, and paying the price in installments, because one of the most important provisions of the sales contract is the transfer of ownership to the buyer. This is only done at the end of the contract.
Second: Financial leasing is not a lease contract, although it includes many provisions of the lease contract, such as a time limit and time-related obligations that fall on the parties to the contract, such as the ownership of the usufruct, rental payments and the financier retaining ownership of the subject of the contract until the end of the term. However, the financial lease contract is characterized by a higher rental value than the rent of a similar value, in addition to the fact that it entails obligations on the financier that are not entailed by the ordinary lease contract.
Third: Financial leasing includes more than one executive stage, and each stage needs certain contractual rules to govern it, which required calling it a financial leasing system.
Fourth: The financial leasing system can be dealt with as an independent system away from any other contract, so that its elements, rules and characteristics are discussed and subjected to legal procedures by experts and specialists, as rules specific to this system and not based on the independent sale contract or the independent lease contract.
Fifth: By reviewing the applications of this system since its inception, we note that some of these forms of application had a specific object: the landlord’s attempt to evade the provisions and obligations of the independent lease contract, which enables him/her to transfer the maintenance and insurance obligations to the financier, and the tenant’s attempt to evade the burden of tax and fees incurred on ownership, since the value of the rental premium that he/she pays is greater than the value of depreciation that is deducted when estimating taxes and fees on the net profit. That is why we ask: those who do not want to own the capital asset at the end of the contract, why do not they apply the ordinary lease contract, and resort to the financial lease?
Sixth: The lessor must be a legal person licensed to practice leasing. The provisions of this contract do not apply to similar relationships that are carried out by a lessor who is not authorized to do so. Many laws agree on this rule. The Kuwaiti law, for example, is one of the countries that explicitly referred to this through the law of establishing leasing companies .
1.Practical forms of financial leasing
By tracing the stages of development of this type of contract in the last half of the 20th century and the beginning of the current century, we find that there are many forms in which financial leasing appeared . Legislations have differed regarding the adaptation of the financial lease contract. The different forms of contract share the nature of leasing, but they may differ according to the leased items and their nature or the nature of the legal relationship that takes place between the parties to it or their special conditions. The most important of these forms in general are:
First: Operating Lease
This type is characterized by the relatively short term of the contract, as this period does not cover the economic life of the capital asset subject of the contract. The application of this contract is predominantly on mechanisms, equipment and devices, which are in constant development and change due to continuous technological progress. This makes the lessee tend to short-term contracts and not to adhere to a long contract that technically restricts its effectiveness, which necessitates the short term of the contract to keep pace with development and modernity. Additionally, what distinguishes this type is that it gives the financier the opportunity to re-lease the asset while the financer is given the opportunity to renew the asset at the end of the contract period. The financier remains committed to the maintenance and insurance consequences .
Second: Financial Leasing
This contract is a long term contract, which usually approximates the operational life of the capital asset subject of the contract, which gives the financer the opportunity to recover the value of the asset, with a reasonable profit margin through rental payments. Also, this contract is characterized by the agreement of its parties that it cannot be canceled before the expiry of its specified period. The consequences of maintenance and insurance often fall on the lessee, while the two parties may agree that the ownership of the asset at the end of the contract term will be transferred to the financier, and by the mechanism that is agreed upon. Therefore, this contract is distinguished from the ordinary lease and from the ordinary sales contract. Hence, it is a novel contract of a special nature, which requires examining its reality and the extent of its legality . The images of this type can be detailed as follows:
1.Direct Lease
This form is characterized by the fact that the contract is made directly between the financer and the financier without the mediation of a third party. This means that the financer relies on his/her own sources to secure the amounts required for financing. The capital asset is often returned to the financer at the end of the contract. By examining this form, I do not find a fundamental difference between the operational lease and the normal lease. The development of this form is surprising in this manner. They do not have any added value except to circumvent the provisions of the ordinary lease with the aim of evading its obligations .
2.Leveraged Leasing
The innovative aspect in this form is the inefficiency of the financer to cover the entire price of the capital asset, so he/she resorts to a third party (a financial broker) to finance the remaining part of the price of the capital asset. This party may be a bank or any other financial institution. This form is distinguished from the previous one in that the financer’s own resources are not sufficient to cover the required amounts. After he/she obtains the capital asset, he/she leases it to the financier. It should be noted that there is absolutely no relationship between the broker and the financier
3.Sale Lease Back
The innovative aspect in this form is that the ownership of the capital asset was originally owned by the financier, but he/she sold this asset to the financer and then rented it from the financer based on a prior agreement, and the aim is to obtain cash .
4.Rent-to-own
The most important thing that distinguishes this form from other forms of financial leasing is the transfer of the ownership of the capital asset to the financier at the end of the contract in one of the ways agreed upon between the two parties. As we explained earlier, this contract is distinguished from the ordinary lease contract and the ordinary sales contract, which makes it a novel contract of a special nature, opening the way for research on its legal and jurisprudential adaptation. Details in this regard will be discussed at a later point of this research. This contract has different forms as follows :
a.Lease ending with transfer of ownership
The contract in this type is concluded as a lease contract that includes the financer’s commitment to grant ownership of the capital asset to the financier with a separate contract, or a promise to grant ownership of the asset at the end of the contract period as soon as the last installment is paid and the transfer of ownership is implemented.
b.Lease associated with the sale at a nominal price
This contract is initially a rental contract and then turns at the end of the rental period into a sale contract, but at a nominal price in return for the financier’s commitment to pay the rental installments throughout the term of the contract.
c.Lease with a promise to sell
In this type, the contract begins with a lease on the capital asset coupled with a promise to sell the asset at the end of the period if the financier so desires. Then, the sale contract is concluded later, either at the market price or at a predetermined and agreed upon price, bearing in mind that the financer has no choice if the financier chooses to buy the capital asset.
d.Rent-to-own (automatic)
Under this contract, the ownership of the capital asset is transferred to the lessee automatically, as soon as the last installment is paid and without the need to conclude any new contract.
e.Lease with the option to own
In this case, a lease contract is concluded on the capital asset, and the financier is given the option to own during or at the end of the term with a new contract at the market price.
Chapter 3: The Legislative Structure and the Practical Reality of the Financial Leasing Contract in Kuwait
In this part of the study, and after discussing the reality of the parties to the financial lease contract, the Kuwaiti legal provisions governing this contract will be clarified and discussed to understand to what extent Kuwaiti law has regulated this contract and to determine the legislative deficiency in this area. Then, we move to discuss the applied reality of this contract in normal conditions, with reference to the extent to which it has been affected by the Corona virus pandemic.
1.The Legislative Structure of the Financial Leasing Contract in Kuwait:
Despite the importance of financial leasing and its applications in Kuwait by banks, especially Islamic banks, such as the Kuwait Finance Bank, Kuwaiti legislation has not yet included an integrated law regulating this issue as other countries have done. However, we find that some aspects of the subject of financial leasing have been raised separately among several laws, as follows:
Law No. 12 of 1998 licensing the establishment of leasing and investment companies. We find a reference to this topic in some texts of the Civil Law and the Trade Law, as well as the law relating to the Central Bank.
The Kuwaiti Civil Law in Article 464 allows delaying the transfer of ownership of the item sold by agreement if the price is deferred or is paid in installments until the fulfillment of the whole payment or part of it, even if the sold item has been delivered. Ownership after fulfilling the payment is considered from the date of the sale and not from the date of fulfilling the payment unless otherwise agreed upon . This form is similar to some of the financial leasing forms that were previously clarified. Through this article, we can derive two necessary points for the establishment of the financial leasing relationship. The first one is finding a guarantee for the lessee through contracting in the form of purchase by installments and receiving the assets, but the ownership remains with the seller. This is a kind of guarantee to obtain the rest of the payment or return the asset if the buyer fails to pay the rest of the installments. The article offers a guarantee in favor of the buyer; if he/she pays all the installments, he/she is considered the owner from the moment of contracting. This is the core of the financial lease ending with ownership. Also, the article is not peremptory. This means that other conditions can be added in accordance with the generally accepted financial leasing provisions.
Law No. 12 of 1998 licensing the establishment of leasing and investment companies. The law consists of seven articles that generally permit and regulate the procedures for establishing leasing and investment companies in Kuwait. The existence of such a law is considered an endorsement of the idea of financial leasing, as it is not reasonable for leasing companies to be established without applying the financial leasing contract. In fact, we find that this law did not include any rules that define the rights and obligations of the parties to the financial lease contract, nor the method of concluding contracts, the provisions that entail them, and how they are terminated. Since the Kuwaiti legislator has permitted the establishment of financial leasing companies, this is useful for the permissibility of conducting and regulating financial leasing contracts according to the will of the parties and applying the general rules of the contract and commercial norms. It is not reasonable to allow the establishment of companies to practice specific work without putting in place special laws regulating the work of a company with a specific purpose.
Kuwaiti Commercial Law No. 68 of 1980 and through Articles 136-140. This law regulates installment sale within the provisions regulating commercial sales. Through these articles, we find that the legislator stipulated provisions for the installment sale contract similar to the provisions of the financial lease contract. Article 136 stipulates that it is not permissible to rule for the termination of the installment sale contract if the buyer has paid the greater part of his/her obligations. This provides a kind of guarantee for the buyer to own the sold item, even if part of the price remains, and even if he/she fails to pay the rest of the price.
Article 137 allows, when selling by installments, that the buyer retains ownership until the payment of the last installment, and that the buyer bears the responsibility of the loss from the time of delivery. In this article, there is a clear reference to some forms of the financial lease contract that ends with ownership upon completion of the payment of installments, and that the buyer at the same time bears the risk of loss. Article 138 included a guarantee for the seller in installments. It did not allow the buyer to dispose of the sale before paying the full installments unless the seller agreed in writing. Third parties shall not benefit from the buyer’s violation of this article if he/she knew at the time of disposal of the seller’s right to money and that some installments are still unpaid. Article 139 also gave another guarantee to the seller. He/she has the right to demand the full installments in the event the buyer disposes of the sale without the seller’s permission. All these provisions and guarantees for the parties to the installment sale contract are considered among the provisions regulating the financial lease contract ending with ownership. Article 140 of this Commercial Law states that “the provisions of the sale in installments stipulated in the previous articles (136-139) shall apply even if the two contracting parties call the sale contract a lease contract. ” This article gave the provisions of the sales contract the priority regarding application, but within the special conditions and guarantees that were given to the seller such as: the right to annul the contract and retain the right of ownership until all installments are paid. The rulings of the Kuwaiti Court of Cassation followed this approach. It has ruled several times that the lease contract coupled with a promise to buy are in fact a sale contract, not a lease contract, and that the value of the agreed rent is in fact the installments of the sale price. (Appeal of Cassation No. 1915 and 2043 of 2013 Commercial / 2, Session 22/6/2014), (Appeal of Cassation No. 651/2010 Commercial /5, Session 9/3/2011).
In light of the rules of civil law and the permissibility of establishing leasing companies, and the provisions of the Kuwaiti Commercial Law in Article 2 regarding the application of commercial custom to commercial disputes and the special nature of Islamic banks and the activities they carry out, which were approved by Law No. 32 of 1968 promulgated for the monetary system, the Central Bank of Kuwait and for regulating the banking profession . The legislator acknowledged the special nature of Islamic banks and that they engage in financing operations with different terms, using the forms of legal contracts such as Murabaha, Musharaka and Mudaraba. Based on all of these texts and commercial custom, which did not oppose the application of financial leasing, it became imperative to acknowledge financial leasing operations in Kuwait, in a manner that is similar to other neighboring countries. This is necessary in order to develop special provisions regulating the work of Islamic banks, especially in Kuwait, since Kuwait applies financial leasing contracts that are consistent with Islamic jurisprudence. As a result, it is necessary to recognize the special nature of the financial lease contract, as it is a contract that merges the lease and sales contract to achieve a kind of guarantees for both parties .
2.Islamic jurisprudence opinions on the financial lease contract
Relevant decisions of the International Islamic Fiqh Council
First: The International Islamic Fiqh Academy decided in the 3rd session held in Amman from 11-16/10/1986 to adopt the following principles:
ðThe IDB’s (Islamic Development Bank) promise to lease the equipment to the client, after it has owned it, is acceptable according to Shariah.
ðThe appointment, by the IDB, of one of its clients as its agent, for the purchase, in the name of the Bank, of equipment and tools, of given specifications and price, with the intention for the Bank to lease the purchased items to this client after the latter has received them, is a Shariah-acceptable agency appointment. However, it is preferable that the purchasing agent be different from the beneficiary client if this condition can be easily met.
ðThe lease agreement should be implemented after the actual acquisition and possession of the equipment and should be in a separate contract than the agency contract or the promise.
ðThe promise to give away the equipment at the end of the lease period is permissible if such a promise is made under a separate contract.
ðThe risk of loss and manufacturing defects rests with the Bank, in its capacity as the equipment owner, unless it is due to deliberate tampering or negligence by the lessee, in which case, the liability will rest with him.
Second: The International Islamic Fiqh Academy decided in the 5th session that was held in Kuwait from 10-15/12/1988, and after reviewing the research papers submitted by members and experts on the subject of rent ending with ownership, it decided :
1.It is a priority to refrain from rent-to-own modes and adopt other alternatives, two of which are as follows:
A.Installment sale after receiving adequate guarantees
B.The rental contract, by which the lesser gives to the lessee the choice, after completing all due installments, between the following options:
• Extension of the rental period,
• Termination of the rental contract and return of the property to its owner,
• Purchase of the rented item at market value at the end of the rental.
2.There are many other forms of rent-to-own contracts, on which the debate has been postponed to the next session, pending the receipt of their sample contracts, with explanations on the realities and conditions governing such contracts. This task will be conducted in collaboration with Islamic Banks, pending further studies and to issue an appropriate resolution in this regard.
Third: The International Islamic Fiqh Academy decided in its 12th session held in Riyadh from 23-28/9/2000 the following :
1.The criteria for the permissible and prohibited forms are as follows:
A.Prohibition Criteria: When the transaction involves conclusion of two different contracts at the same time, for the same commodity and for the same duration.
B.Permissibility Criteria:
• The presence of two completely separate and independent contracts as to the time of their conclusion, and in which the sale contract succeeds the lease contract or the presence of a promise allowing the lessee to become the owner at the end of the contractual.
• The existence of a genuine desire from both parties to conclude the lease contract and not just to use it as a mere veil for the sale contract.
C.The leased property should be guaranteed by the owner and not the lessee. In this sense, the owner should bear any damage that is not caused by the lessee’s misuse or the lessee has nothing to bear, even if such damage has rendered the property completely useless.
D.If the contract includes property insurance, the cooperative insurance should be non-commercial, Shariah-compliant, and the sole liability of the lessor and not by the lessee.
E.During the entire lease period, the contract should be subjected to Shariah rulings regarding Ijara, whereas Shariah rulings on ownership should be observed when the property ownership is transferred to the lessee.
F.The cost of maintenance, excluding operational expenses, should be borne by the lessor and not by the lessee during the entire lease period.
2.Some Prohibited Forms
A.A Renting Ending in Ownership contract that leads to the transfer of ownership to the lessee against the amounts of rent he pays during the contract period, without signing a separate sale. In other words, it is when the same lease contract automatically changes into a sale contract.
B.A Lease contract according to which the property is given to the lessee against a specific amount of rent and for a specific duration, coupled with a sale contract that becomes effective only when the lessee pays the whole amount of rent agreed upon, or at a specified date in the future.
C.An appropriate lease contract including an option for the owner to sell the property to the lessee, at the end of the leasing period.
3.Some Permissible Forms
A.A lease contract that allows the lessee to make use of the leased property against a specific amount of rent and for a specific period, along with a separate contract offering the property as a gift to the latter, after the lease period and full payment of due rent, as per the Academy resolution no. 13 (1/3) on Hibah (gifts) at its third session.
B.A lease contract offering the option to the lessee to purchase the property, after the lease period and the full payment of due rent, at the then-prevailing market price, as per the Academy resolution 44 (6/5) at its fourth session.
C.A lease contract that allows the lessee to use the leased property against a specific rent amount and for a specific period coupled with a promise from the owner to sell the property to the lessee, after the full payment of due rent, at a price to be mutually agreed
D.A lease contract that allows the lessee to make use of the leased property for a specific amount of rent and a specific period, while the owner gives the option to the lessee to own the property at any time if he so The sale, in this case, is to be made according to a new contract in due time and at the then-prevailing market price, as per Academy resolution no. 44 (6/5), or at any other price to be agreed upon at the time of concluding the sale contract.
4.There are some other forms of Renting Ending in Ownership that still remain controversial among Fuqahā (fiqh scholars). These forms require a thorough study to be presented to the Academy in one of its forthcoming sessions.
Based on the weighting of the first form that was mentioned in the decision of the Islamic Fiqh Academy in its 12th session, which states: “a lease contract that allows the lessee to use the leased property against a specific rent amount and for a specific period coupled with a promise from the owner to sell the property to the lessee, after the full payment of due rent, with an independent contract, or a promise to gift it after the full payment of the rent.” This form will be adopted as an application in this research. I believe that this form is the most compatible with the legal rulings . As for the item subject of the contract, it can be real estate or movable. In the case of real estate, the situation is more difficult, given the procedures that the real estate requires. Therefore, the real estate will be approved as a subject of the contract, especially residential buildings because they are the most difficult in the field of real estate. The purpose is that if the difficult cases are resolved, the other, easier, cases will not require lengthy discussions to be dealt with. Additionally, this approach serves the objectives of this study.
3.The importance of the financial lease contract during emergency circumstances (the use of the contract in light of the Corona virus pandemic)
As we have indicated earlier, this contract was not vastly applied on the ground in the financial and banking institutions for various reasons, the most important of which was the lack of special legal legislation that defines the obligations of each of the contracting parties. This forces the litigants to resort to the provisions of the general laws that govern this contractual relationship and the procedures that these laws entailed, which are not in accordance with the nature of this contract and its specificity with regard to non-Islamic financial and banking institutions. As for the Islamic financial and banking institutions, the situation was worse. In addition to being affected by the same causes facing other forms, it has faced another special reason. This reason was represented by the introduction of the structured banking tawarruq – with our reservation about its legal permissibility – at a time when it was focusing on the method of murabaha for the ordering to buy, it marginalized the rest of the financing methods, including the financial leasing method. We do not wish to offend this method when we say that with the introduction of the organized banking tawarruq, the rest of the forms have almost been put to halt, including the financial leasing method. This takes place in normal conditions, without having to go through crises, emergencies or force majeure circumstances. However, with the emergence of the Corona virus pandemic, the situation has become completely different. It is natural for this change to be for the worst, which will be addressed in the following discussion.
In this part of the study, the objective will be to discuss the relationship between emergency conditions and the financial leasing contract, by examining the Covid-19 pandemic (Corona virus) on financial leasing activities. The aim of the discussion is to discuss to what extent this crisis has negatively affected this contract, as well as how this contract can be used to contribute to alleviating the negative economic impact of the pandemic on the national economy of any country. Since the financial leasing contract is linked to the process of investing the funds of finance companies, while the receiving party aims to benefit from the financing to improve his/her business and strengthen its financial position, any emergency circumstance may have an impact on the parties to the contract. It is not possible to isolate the investment environment in general from the surrounding political, social and economic changes. Emergency conditions may be positive mutations and lead to an improvement in the work environment for the parties to the financial leasing contract or for some of them, and may also be negative, such as the Covid-19 pandemic. This pandemic has in general led to a slowdown in economic growth, stagnation in goods and a lack of demand for services as a result of lockdowns, lack of movement, restrictions on individuals, and obstruction of export and import.
There is no doubt that obstructing the economic movement due to any emergency will have a negative impact on the financing request, whether it is direct cash financing or financing through financial leasing because there is no need for financing. Nevertheless, even in this stagnation situation, one of the benefits of financial leasing appeared, which is the guarantee in favor of the finance company, because it has the right to recover the assets with which it financed companies that were on the verge of bankruptcy as a result of crises. Additionally, these assets will not be part of the capital of the companies that are declared bankrupt and will not be included in the liquidation since the leased property remains owned by the lessor before and until the end of the contract term . As for the financier that is liquidated, there is a positive aspect in the financial leasing that it gets rid of part of its obligations by returning the leased assets to the finance companies without being obligated to pay the rest of the installments. When these companies recover, it is easy for them to re-finance by renting back the same or other assets from the same or other financers.
There is another way in which financial leasing can be used during times of crisis as a way to obtain cash when companies face difficulty in obtaining the loan . Companies that have stumbled and need cash can sell their capital assets to financial leasing companies and then rent them in monthly installments through the lease contract. Thus, it can obtain the cash it needs to continue its work and at the same time maintain its capital assets. This is what was explicitly adopted by the Jordanian legislator .
The laws and instructions by which financial leasing companies are controlled by the financiers can also be used as a complement to the national policy to mitigate economic crises, as is the case in the Arab Republic of Egypt. Egypt has issued official instructions to the financial leasing companies to periodically monitor the companies that are financed to ensure that the financing is used in a way that achieves its purpose, which is real operation and cash flow tracking . The purpose of enabling and obligating finance companies to monitor is to ensure that national projects play their role to mitigate the negative effects of the Corona virus pandemic, to avoid misusing financing, and to ensure the sustainability of revitalizing the economy. The oversight that takes place here is justified from a legal point of view as the finance companies have the right to monitor the assets they still own to ensure that the lessee does not dispose of them by selling them.
Another aspect that financial leasing may help with during crises is the speed of obtaining capital support through financial leasing to accelerate the establishment of new industries that were needed during the Corona virus pandemic that are related to consumables, especially cleaning and sterilization materials and other medical materials that have become important in all countries. Here, one of the benefits of financial leasing appears once again, which is to obtain capital assets for productive projects for people with creative ideas who do not have sufficient capital to start their business.
Conclusion and recommendations
The financial leasing system has been adopted in most countries of the world as a modern method to ensure that businesses obtain financing for the capital assets they need, whether movables such as production equipment or real estate without the need to borrow and without consuming the available capital in the direct purchase of assets. The importance of the financial leasing contract is in its effectiveness in achieving the interests of the investing institutions for the cash capital available to them through their purchase of capital assets and re-leasing them through long-term contracts through which they restore capital and a profit margin and by ensuring that the ownership of the assets remains for the lessor during the validity of the contract. Likewise, the financial leasing contract defines the rights and obligations of the supplier towards the lessor by means of a sale contract and the specifications of the leased property as specified by the lessee.
The financial lease contract is beneficial since it is used within certain controls. It is suitable for application by Islamic financial institutions because interest-based lending is avoided. This is done through the contract that ends with the real and actual transfer of ownership of the property from the financer to the financier (ending with ownership). If a question is raised in regards to why we do not resort to applying the installment sale contract, which transfers ownership from the moment of contracting even if part of the price remains, we can say that: the lessor’s retention of ownership despite the delivery of the property to the applicant for financing is to preserve the right of the lessor from the bad faith of the lessee or failure to fulfill the obligations until the completion of the contract until the completion of the payment of the price of the rental value payments.
As for the extent to which the finance lease contract is applied in Kuwait, we find that Kuwaiti legislation in general, as stated in some provisions related to capital financing operations and the nature of the work of financial institutions in financial leasing, did not reject the application of financial leasing. It rather indirectly approved some forms of financial leasing. Therefore, we call on the Kuwaiti legislator to put in place an integrated law regulating the financial leasing contract with its special nature that combines the sale of the lease contract and the contract of sale, as many countries have done. It is preferable that the law be consistent with the rules of Islamic legislation so that it can be applied by Islamic financial institutions that are not permitted to conduct interest-based transactions.
Recommendations
At the end of this study, some recommendations can be made, which can be summarized as follows:
1.The accurate information about the financial leasing contract and the possibility of using it by those who need financing and do not wish to engage in interest-based transactions must be published. This is in line with the level of knowledge of many people in this country and other Islamic countries.
2.Encouraging the use of financial leasing will contribute to creating new investments, especially if the person does not have sufficient security or does not want to risk all the cash capital in purchasing equipment and production tools.
3.Developing a disciplined legislative structure for the financial leasing contract and the guarantees it contains for all parties to the capital financing process contributes to increasing the ability of Arab institutions to compete on the national and international arena, which contributes to increasing their financial strength and encourages individuals to apply for Islamic sukuk.
4.There is a fierce jurisprudential debate regarding the legality of financial leasing, and the reason for this is the multiplicity of its forms, some of which are in accordance with the provisions of Islamic Sharia, and others that are contrary to it. For this reason, experienced scholars in legal matters must study and analyze the shortcomings of this system as an attempt to put an end to this debate and to find out the best forms that conform to Sharia rulings.
5.The Kuwaiti legislator must recognize the special nature of the financial leasing contract and not limit its provisions to those of the sales contract. It should also establish a special legislation regulating this contract in a manner commensurate with the provisions of Islamic jurisprudence in a manner that serves the Kuwaiti Islamic financial institutions. The main purpose is to avoid conflicts and encourage this form as a safe means of financing, which helps economic growth.
References
1.Balawi: Safaa. Legal Aspects of the Financial Leasing Contract and its Tax Regulation, An-Najah National University, Master’s Thesis, 2005.
2.Kuwait Finance House: Proceedings of the first jurisprudence symposium of the Kuwait Finance House, held in Kuwait from 7-11 March 1987.
3.Mohammed Al-Etribi. Kuwaiti Gazette, Issue 4702. Date 4/28/2015. https://www.aljarida.com/articles/1462412417245212700/ Viewed date 4-5-2021
4.Hassan: Ismail. Financial Leasing of Assets and Equipment in Islamic Banks, Journal of Islamic Economics, No. 71, 1987.
5.Al-Khatib: Ishraq Mahmoud Jamil, 1998, Casuistry in the Field of Economics. Unpublished Master’s Thesis, College of Sharia, Yarmouk University, Jordan, 1998.
6.Dowidar: Hani Muhammad. The Legal System of Financial Leasing. Al-Montazah – Misr Reconstruction Towers, Al-Rasaa Technical Library and Printing Press, 2nd edition, 1998.
7.Dunia: Shawqi Ahmed. Lease ending with Ownership – Diminishing Musharaka/partnership: One of the Islamic financial instruments for financing projects. Journal of Saleh Kamel Center for Islamic Economics – Al-Azhar University, No. 9, 1999.
8.Al-Rashidi: Muhammad Abdullah. Master’s thesis entitled: The lease contract ending with ownership – a comparative study with Islamic Sharia. Jordan Middle East University 2010.
9.Zaid: Muhammad Abdul Aziz Hassan. Leasing between Islamic Jurisprudence and Contemporary Application in Islamic Banking and Financial Institutions. Cairo, International Institute of Islamic Thought, 1996.
10. Al-Salami: Muhammad Al-Mukhtar. Lease ending Ownership and Lease Sukuk. Journal of the Islamic Fiqh Academy, Jeddah, 12th Session, 2000.
11. Alshwaiyat: Mahmoud Salim, Activating the Financial Leasing System in Islamic Financial Institutions. Master’s Thesis, Yarmouk University, Jordan, Dar Al-Manthama, 2004.
12. Abdel Aziz: Samir Muhammad. Financial Leasing and its Financial Leasing and its Financial, Accounting, Legislative and Economic Applied Approaches. Alexandria, Al Isha’a Technical Library and Press, 2000.
13. Abu Atmeh: Suleiman. An article published in the Jordanian Al-Anbat newspaper titled Corona Virus and Financial Leasing Companies, 14/5/2020, https://alanbatnews.net/article/285015, access date 6/3/2021.
14. Al-Ali: Yousef, Al- Rushud: Ahmed. Leasing in Kuwaiti Law: a Study of the Concept of Leasing, the Organization of its Companies, and the Resolution of Conflict of Laws in this regard. Law Journal, Kuwait University, Volume 31: Issue 2, 2007.
15. Omar: Muhammad Abdul Halim. Financial Leasing from an Islamic Perspective. Journal of Saleh Kamel Center for Islamic Economics – Al-Azhar University, No. 7, 1999
16.Al-Qaradaghi: Ali Mohieddin Ali. Researches in the Jurisprudence of Contemporary Financial Transactions. Beirut, Dar Al-Bashaer Al-Islamiyyah, 1st edition, 2001.
17.Qudah: Adam. Qudah: Musa. The duties and rights of the lessee and the lessor in the financial leasing: a comparative study between Islamic jurisprudence and Jordanian law. Journal of Shari’a Studies and Law Sciences, Issue 43 (1), 2016.
18.Abulail: Ibrahim Desouki. Installment Sales and Other Credit Sales. Kuwait University, University Publications, 1st Edition, 1984.
19.Mahasna: Nesreen. Financial Leasing in Jordanian Law compared to Lease Ending with Ownership According to Islamic Jurisprudence. Journal of Law, Kuwait University, Volume 32, Issue 4, 2008.
20.Al-Masaeed: Suleiman Wared Mayouf, 1994, The Lease-to-own Contract, a Comparative Study between Islamic Sharia and Contemporary Systems, Unpublished Master’s Thesis, College of Sharia, Yarmouk University, Jordan, 1994.
21.Al-Maaytah: Yahya. The legal system for the risks to which the lessee is exposed in the financial lease contract. Master’s Thesis, 2012, Jordan Middle East University.
22.Al Mqabalah: Ali. Judeh: Mahfouz. Obstacles of Financial Leasing in Jordan. Mutah for Research and Studies, Volume 18, Number 4, Mutah University, 2003.
23.Al-Munai’i: Muhammad bin Suleiman bin Othman. Leasing ending with Ownership, a comparative jurisprudential study (refereed research). Justice Journal, Issue 13, Fourth Year, Muharram 1422 AH.
24.Abdul-Mawjood: Adel Ahmed et al., Supplementation of Al-Majmo’, Sharh Al-Muhadhab. Volume 16, Beirut, Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya, 2002.
25.Journal of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy, 3rd Session, No. 3, Part 1, 1987.
26.Journal of the International Islamic Fiqh Academy, 5th Session, No. 5, Part 4, 1988.
27.Law No. 12 of 1998 Licensing the Establishment of Leasing and Investment Companies.
28.Jordanian Financial Leasing Law No. 45 of 2008.
29.Law No. 176 of 2018 Promulgating the Law Regulating Financial Leasing and Factoring Activities.
30.Federal Law No. 8 of 2018 Concerning Financial Leasing.
31.Uniform Commercial Code: Finance lease: ARTICLE 2A -103 LEASES (2002) (g) https://www.law.cornell.edu /ucc/2A, accessed on 25.4.2021.
32.UNIDROIT Convention on International Financial Leasing 1988: https://www.jus.uio.no/lm/unidroit.financial.leasing.convention.1988/doc.html
33.Decree-Law No. 67 of 1980 promulgating the Civil Law 1980/67.
34.Kuwaiti Commercial Law No. 68 of 1980
35.The Monetary Law and the Central Bank of Kuwait No. 30 of 2003.




